If you've been staring at the size chart wondering whether to go with **Hollister S vs XS**, you're not alone. As someone who's tried on probably too many Hollister pieces for my weekly livestreams, I get the struggle. Sizing can be inconsistent, and the difference between a small and an extra small can make or break the fit. In this honest review, I'm breaking down everything you need to know about this size comparison—measurements, fit on different body types, and my final keep-it-or-return-it verdict. So grab your measuring tape, and let's dive in.
Understanding Hollister’s Size Chart
Hollister runs a bit generous compared to other mall brands like American Eagle or Abercrombie & Fitch. A standard XS typically fits a 0-2, and S fits a 2-4, but that's a loose guideline. The brand's official size chart lists XS as bust 31-32.5", waist 23-24.5", hips 33-34.5"; S as bust 32.5-34", waist 24.5-26", hips 34.5-36". That's about a 1.5-inch difference in key measurements. However, some items—like their cropped sweaters or ribbed tops—run smaller. For example, the "Hollister Selena Ribbed Tank" in XS fits like a true 0, but the same in S fits like a 4. Always check the fabric composition: cotton-poly blends have less give, while spandex blends stretch more. Also, jackets and denim are usually more rigid, so you might need to size up for those.
How I Tested Both Sizes
I ordered the same three pieces in both sizes: a basic bodysuit ($18 during sale), a ribbed tank ($25), and a pair of high-waisted jeans ($55). For reference, I'm 5'4", 120 lbs, with a 34B bust and 26" waist. My measurements technically straddle the boundary between XS and S. In the bodysuit, the XS was snug but wearable, while the S had slight gapping at the back. In the ribbed tank, XS was perfect—snug through the arms and torso; S was too loose around the arms, creating gaping. The jeans were a different story: the XS was too tight in the thighs and gave me a muffin top, but S fit like a dream everywhere. That's why ordering both can save you a return trip.
Key Fit Differences Between S and XS
The most noticeable difference is in the shoulders and bust. If you're between sizes, a **Hollister S vs XS** decision often comes down to your bust measurement. For A/B cups, XS usually works well. For C/D cups, you might need the extra room in S to avoid pulling at the buttons or zipper. Also, Hollister's stretchy fabrics (like their cotton-spandex blends) give you more flexibility, but structured pieces like denim jackets or non-stretch shirts run true to size. The rule of thumb? If you want a relaxed, boyfriend-fit look, go S. If you prefer a cropped, fitted silhouette, go XS.
Comparing Specific Items: Bodysuit, Tank, and Jeans
Let's break down the three items I tested. The bodysuit: XS gave a sleek, second-skin feel; S had looseness at the back. I kept the XS. The ribbed tank: XS hugged my curves; S was baggy. Kept XS. The jeans: XS was too tight; S was perfect. I kept S. So even for one body type, whether to pick the small or extra small varies by item. Always consider the fabric and cut. For tops with elastic, favor XS; for denim, favor S.
Who Should Choose XS?
Choose XS if you are typically a 0-2 in other brands, have a smaller bust (A to small B), and prefer a snug, cropped fit. If you're under 5'3", XS will also give you shorter sleeves and torso length—ideal for petites. Items like the classic Hollister muscle tee or their bodysuits look best in XS for a sleek silhouette. However, if you plan to eat a big meal or like to breathe, maybe size up.
Who Should Choose S?
Choose S if you're usually a size 4, have a medium bust (B to C), or want more room through the hips and thighs. Denim runs small, so if you're between sizes, always go S in jeans. Also, if you prefer a looser, more oversized fit in tops, S is your friend. For the uninitiated, **Hollister S vs XS** in sweaters can mean the difference between a cozy fit and one that's too tight. In their "Ezra Fleece Pullover", S gives that cute slouchy look while XS fits like a second layer.
Keep It or Return It: My Verdict
For me, the **Hollister S vs XS** question depends on the item. For tops with spandex, XS is fine. For denim and structured pieces, S fits better. My honest verdict: If you're on the fence, order both sizes and return the one that doesn't work. Hollister's free returns make it easy. In general, I keep the larger size for bottoms and smaller for tops. But that's just me—your experience may vary!
Final Tips for Sizing
Always check the fabric content. Cotton-poly blends have less give than spandex blends. Also, read reviews—other shoppers often note "this runs small" or "size down." If you can, visit a store to try before buying. But if you're ordering online, now you have the full picture on **Hollister S vs XS**. Hope this helps—keep it or return it, you decide!
That's all for this size comparison. I hope it saves you a few returns. Let me know in the comments which size worked for you!
No notes yet — write the first one.